Search This Blog

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Irithiel of the Leafy Shade, elf longevity and the lifespan of empires

 I often don't like the way elves are presented in RPGs, to the point that I often include them only passively, through players hearing about them but never meeting them. Often my players have been no more keen to play them that I am to introduce them, so it has worked fine.

Recently things have changed. I've run games with younger players and, of course, Rings Of Power has happened. Elves, it turns out, are cool. 

In the post Jackdog Town, I mentioned Irithiel of the Leafy Shade: 

The Emissary of the Elves, Irithiel of the Leafy Shade. This role was forced upon Irithiel, as emissary duty to humans always is, as it is basically punishment duty, though nonetheless undertaken with all sobriety and gravity. Now forced to try and understand the halfwits that are humans and even remain on good terms with some of them. 

First, that word 'Emissary'. Elves do send a member of their kind to some human settlements to represent them in some way, or to learn about humans. Okay. But its punishment duty. Nobody wants to do it because humans are crass and stupid and their art and culture are terrible. So is the food.

Flip side of this: Irithiel is no angel. They did something that pissed off all their peers enough to be... well, sent into exile, effectively. That could be something pretty serious. We have no timescale to go on, here, and I'll talk about lifespans later, but we usually assume elves live long, to some extent or other. So a ten year stretch in 'humanland' might not be such a big deal. of course, it might be longer... 

Which kind of brings us to a question that has probably been raised at countless gaming tables since 1974, and was recently raised at mine: how long do elves live?

There are a range of lifespans given for elves across different TTRPGs.

In Pathfinder 2e, they get about 600 years, which is decent. In Warhammer Fantasy they get over 1000, which is more decent. Shadowrun gives them 300 or 400 and Dragonage only gives them 80 to 120 years. Tight! Then there is The One Ring, of course, which makes them immortal, as Tolkien intended... 

I asked my players what they wanted. One said 130, barely out of adolescence, a young elf. Fine. Another said '"Thousands of years...". And my reaction was complicated. I was torn. Between "Yikes! How am I going to manage all the stuff he knows about the world? Why is he still only Level 1?" and "Cool...".

I went with the Rule Of Cool. 

We still haven't settled on an exact number of thousands, however, and there is some stuff to unpack around that I thought would be interesting to reflect on here, because I graduated in History and have a strong interest in Medieval and Ancient History.

 The main question worth asking, I think, is "What difference will it make at the table?" This is always my first question. The next question is "What are the implications for world-building?" which I think in the long run, may be the more impactful.

The first question is actually simple to answer. In Tales Of Argosa, which I'm currently running, and most other games, it make NO difference at all. And that's fine. I used to struggle with how a 500 year old being is still first level, now I don't. I. Just. Don't. No fulfilment lies therein. Separate the mechanics and the world in your head and let it be. Learn acceptance. Think about more important things.  I mean sure you can give them a bit more background knowledge but in terms of mechanics... meh. 

Almost any path you go down that is any way 'realistic' (or 'simulationist', if you prefer) makes elf characters overpowered, so it's better just to rely on in-world knowledge or nothing at all and assume they had a sheltered life OR that Level 1 stats represent an average being of any race/species.

In terms of world-building, its a slightly different matter, though. I was thinking about how a very long elf lifespan would see the world around them. I did some research into the timescale of a particular popular fantasy trope: the Empire.

By some measures, the Chinese Empire could be described as the longest lasting empire in history, at 2,132 years, from 221BC to 1912CE. But it usually isn't, as most historians see it as a succession of distinct empires, (which we refer to as dynasties). While the fundamental bureaucracy, writing system and cultural identity remained constant, the ruling families changed entirely many times. There were periods of fragmentation and long periods of division. Most of the dynasties lasted 200 to 300 years, which is in line with most empires. 

The Roman Empire is often cited as the longest lasting major empire, if you count (and you should) the continuation of the Eastern Roman Empire. That gives a duration of about 1500 years, from the rise of Augustus in 27 BCE to the fall of Constantinople in 1453 CE. Of course, the Republic probably began around 500 BCE... 

The Pandyan dynasty in southern India stretched across 1800 year but with interruptions. The Kanem-Bornu Empire lasted about 1000 years. The Holy Roman Empire only lasted 844 years and the ottoman Empire 623 years.

Empires don't last that long. At least, not in comparison to elves.

Elves with thousands of years' lifespan would outlive most empires several times over. Why wouldn't they assist such empires to last longer and become more 'civilised' or 'humane' than many of the empires I've mentioned were? Some of these questions of course, are answered, or at least asked, more often in vampire fiction, than in fantasy. immortality, as such fiction often shows, comes at a price. 

Ultimately, it doesn't matter how you answer these questions, but I feel you must answer it (or I must) if your elves live that long, in order to preserve any sense of verisimilitude.

If you decide your elves enjoy extreme longevity, then how many empires do you want your elf player character to remember? Put another way, how many do you want to have to invent or describe to your players? And it gets worse, not better, if you don't have empires. Empires are easy. Without one, you have a dozen smaller states to describe that are all much less stable, shift borders, invade each other, suffer catastrophes like plages and earthquakes, develop new religions, disappear... Horrible. 

My decision has been formulated like this:

My campaign world has an empire already, coming to the end of its lifespan. I am now going to say its about 1500 years old. The older elf character can remember its inception and a little of what came before (vaguely... it was messy and very human...). That way, the character becomes a channel for me to communicate anything i want about the empire. 

If we go back any further things get tricky.

If we use Europe as a guide, 6000 years ago, farming was spreading out of Anatolia into western Europe. Soon after, it reached Britain and Ireland. Weaving was taking off. We don't really know how long the spread of these ideas took exactly but probably between 2500 and 3000 years. If your elves live much longer than that, then they pretty much all saw the rise of humanity and human scholars have NO questions they can't answer, there is NO history that is not known and there are NO mysteries left to unearth. 

In addition, elves would probably have been involved the whole time, there at the beginning, so to speak, so would have had an impact.

For this reason, I think its better if they are not too long-lived. 

If elves live for say, 3000 years, then an elf lifespan would still mostly cover the spread of civilisation across a whole region, just. An elf that old now in my world can remember the rise of the local empire and some of what came before, maybe the initial war of conquest, the state that gave rise to it, the emperor as a child. But they wouldn't remember first hand what came before. And any elves younger than that (i.e. most of them) would not remember a time when humans didn't farm, but might remember times when they were not so good at it. There can still be things they don't know (like the time when humans arose before, or the empire of giants, etc) and there can be things their parents told them about seeing, but they were not there for. And of course, there can be older beings and races/species and cultures. 

 Which raises an interesting point about our friend Irithiel.

 How old are they? And how does that impact on their role as emissary to Jackdog Town? Because I would normally associate roles such as 'emissary' with mature, probably powerful individuals. But if its a punishment duty, that might suggest someone young enough to make a mistake. I think it might be something decided on a case by case basis. Either way, Irithiel is there and they're the only elf, most of the time, and they're going to be bored. 

 What is Irithiel doing in that time? Well they'd probably go nuts if they were doing nothing, so lets not make that assumption. They could, of course, just get bored and take themselves off a-wandering.  And I guess that's where elf adventurers come from. Of they could bard it up for a while, doubtless gaining renowned as the finest in the land. But unless they're in a big city, that just seems mean to all the human bards struggling to make a name and get by. If you go a little bit Tolkien here, they could spend their time teaching humans about music and song, elf history, etc. But only those humans wealthy enough not to spend all day in a field. Irithiel would end up a 'court bard' pretty quick, or at least ensconced in the local castle or keep. Which might be no bad thing. Yes, that could work quite well.

If not, maybe they serve as emissary within a wider area. A kind of travelling representative, spending a few weeks in each settlement, with a well-earned break from human yammering, on the roads between. 

And for how long would they be carrying out this duty? Well I suppose there's no fixed rule; the elf elders with responsibility for oversight of Irithiel would choose a time to 'extract' him that caused minimum disruption to human affairs. If the local lord is stable and secure and his domain the same, then an elf in exile could potentially spend a human lifetime there. Say, thirty years or more. And of an elf can reliably expect to live 3000 years, that 1% of their lifetime, the equivalent of about eight months, to a human who lives to be 70. An elf could learn a lot about humans in that time. A not teach anything dangerous in return, if they're a young individual. If the domain falls into civil war, however, or is subject to plague or invasion, then maybe you pull Irithiel out, deploy them somewhere safer. 

We should not discount the possibility that there could be a specific and possibly dark purpose to an elf's investigating, either. They could be trying to understand how much of a threat human populations pose to elf. Or there might be reason to suspect a greater threat at large in the area (a la Necromancer in the forest). Or they might be tasked with finding out how a local sorcerer nobody used to take notice of has somehow mustered an army of lion-folk. 

 All of which points to a couple of conclusions. 

There is nothing wrong with giving elves serious longevity. We will need to think about it a bit more, but it will also allow his to feed more background to players if we need to. 

We need to answer a few questions, one way or another, such as exact longevity influence upon human culture, deep history, etc. in order to build elves more fully into our campaign setting, including  how much history we actually want write/read/have to remember.

And we should consider whether our particular answers to any of these questions are likely to influence whether or not players actually choose to play elves. Because at the end of the day, that's the whole point. 

 

Trouble In Jackdog Town

 In a previous post, Shokan's Place, I wrote about the Shire Reeve of Jackdog Town, Duncan of Trie, the Bishop, Aukinslade of Drimsdale, and a Knight, Sir Belicassus of Erstwhere. I also mentioned in passing, Duncan's Captain of the Guard, Captain Stargadder.

I want to develop these relationships a little more.

Bishop Aukinslade  is suspicious. Being of a minor noble line himself (which doesn't count for much any more, now he has moved to the frontier), he has  certain expectations of other nobility. And Sir Duncan isn't meeting them. In fact, Duncan is showing neither the piety, manner or good grace that the Bishop has come to expect. Duncan behaves, at times, more like a thug than a protector of the one Church. He doesn't have the education for the Bishop to indulge in the refined conversation he is yearning for (nothing unusual in itself). In fact, Duncan seems clearly more akin to his own Captain, Stargadder, who Aukinslade is pretty sure has acted as a mercenary at least once in his life, from things the man has let slip during unguarded moments. 

Aukinslade is justified in his suspicions. The man who appears to be Sir Duncan of Trie, in fact, is the Red Raven, Cauven Linsdale, a once murderous and ruthless bandit. Recently, Cauven was handed an opportunity to change his circumstances, when he ambushed the real Sir Duncan on his way to take up the post of Shire Reeve at Jackdog Town.  After killing his small detachment of mounted men-at-arms in a bloody battle in the forest, Cauven found papers that explained the dead knights own situation. Then Cauven Linsdale, Red Raven, assumed the dead man's identity and his men those of the soldiers, and continued to Jackdog Town. 

 Oddly enough, Cauven intends not to ravage or plunder the town, but to take up the post as well as he can, perform whatever duties he can work out that he is supposed to do, and safeguard the border. His simple hope is that by doing this, he will evade capture or notice and live out his days there.

Sir Belicassus, on the other hand, is every bit the knight of tradition and ballad. If anything, he is overly romantic. And although he has many enemies, there is one in particular, though he will always generalise where possible. Belicassus has a particular hate and loathing for those men of the Old Country who have come to the New Lands and instead of living in peace with their neighbours while toiling to build and new and better life, break laws, kill innocents and rob from others, just like they used to before. These men he considers rabid dogs, to be hunted down and removed from everyone's misery.

One such man is the Red Raven, a vicious outlaw, renowned across the region, said to have burned whole villages just to get their loot. The Red Raven has stopped operating these last couple of years and when Sir Duncan is asked about the rogue, he usually shrugs and says the man must have retired. Belicassus has never met Cauven Linsdale, and so has no idea what he looks like.

 Lona Dearhart was raised with money and care but not by her parents. Because her father was Sir Duncan of Trie and her mother was a barmaid in Shokan's place, who died when Lona was young. After that, Lona lived by her wits and hard work, serving in places that offered her opportunities to earn extra money on the side, whether by legitimate means or otherwise. Somewhere along the way, she learned all manner of games of chance, from knuckles to dice, and from backgammon to dominoes. Everyone says don't play against her when she's wearing green...  

 Hopefully this collection of NPCs offers some opportunity of  'background plots' in Jackdog Town, between more tangible adventures. If the players show no direct inclination to pursue them that's fine: I can gently move each component along as I like, to help make the setting feel alive. 

 


 

 

 

Saturday, 14 November 2026

Dokkaebi

 So I was reading Gus L's excellent analysis of The Dragon Of Icespire Peak, here, on All Dead Generations. If you haven't read it, do so. Because in a way, his review can act as a kind of mini-guide to how campaigns should be structured. 

I was struck by what he says about orcs being a wasted opportunity in that campaign because you can't negotiate with them and they're predictable and its always going to end in a fight. I realised this was true in some of my own stuff where I had deliberately swapped out orcs for something else. My go-to swap has been hobgoblins,but they can easily fall into the same stereotype and often, I end up playing them as something very different from, well hobgoblins.

For my Dark Peak setting, I wanted to include a creature the players were not already familiar with. So I looked around. And I found the korean Dokkaebi.

Now  I could change their name in a campaign, but so far, I've chosen not to in my notes because I want to remember where they come from. 

But what I took away from my reading about them on the internet (okay, not that extensive as research goes, but sufficient for my own game),  is that they are unpredictable. That's kind of their thing. They might be helpful, mischievous or aggressive. I don't want to randomise these responses too much, in game, because if they become too unpredictable, the players won't want to interact with them. And I very much want them to do that. But if I were writing a campaign that was kind-of-inspired by The Dragon Of Icespire, then I would use these in place of orcs and I would do this everywhere orcs might otherwise crop up in that setting (I don't usually use orcs anyway, for all of these reasons) with the express intent that PCs could negotiate with them without them being totally reliable. And without different groups of Dokkaebi being the same. One groups is cool; they negotiate and play fair. Another group has a different outlook. They cheat and steal and commit murder.

Okay, that's the  play dynamic I'm after. If you want a summary of the real world Dokkaebi, you can look online; Wikipedia has a good page. What follows is how they will appear in my campaign.

In the korean mythology, Dokkaebi seem to mainly appear as yellow or red. I'm going with red; I can introduce a yellow population later if I want to. They are red, not red-brown, not 'redskins', not reddish but a non-human, unmistakable red. They sometimes have horns. They sometimes have beards and wild hair. They have large teeth which sometimes appear to be tusks. And they have large features, such as eyes, nose, etc. I'm giving mine large ears with hairy tufts like a red squirrel. Just because. Oh and they are human sized. Done. 

Dokkaebi are not fey; that's a western tradition and therefore well-worn, and also has been boxed and sold already by WOTC et al. I'm not interested in explaining exactly what Dokkaebi ARE, and I won't explain it in my campaign either, other than that mages say they exist differently, and thus have power over different things than humans. So, Dokkaebi are  potent against evil spirits. Any rolls they make to banish, intimidate or expel supernatural beings gains a +2 bonus, which becomes Advantage against beings with lower Hit Dice than the Dokkaebi.

Dokkaebi also know how to ensure a good harvest, good catches of fish and general prosperity. This is knowledge-based. They have knowledge of fungi, the nitrogen cycle, etc..

But they can also carry disease, such as Black Speckle Fever. Not all Dokkaebi have this, and it isn't easy to catch, but if a human does get infected, its unpleasant. It doesn't spread from human to human, which is why Dokkaebi have the reputation for carrying it.

Due to the intrinsically magical nature of Dokkaebi, their exended presence can cause a human's perception of reality to shift, or even falter. They can essentially cause a condition in humans that appears a little like what humans call 'madness'; at the GM's discretion, after each week spent in daily contact with Dokkaebi, a successful Will save is needed, to avoid a roll on the Madness table on p161 (at GM's further discretion count only even-numbered results). 

Dokkaebi often make sue of mystical clubs or hats. The hats confer the spell  Limited Transmogrification, which can transform the wearer a number of times equal to their level, into a member of another humanoid race. Clubs confer one of the following spells (d4) Dark Slumber, Crush of the Warp, None Shall Pass or Shadows And Dust. 

STATS

DOKKAEBI

#4d6 AC11 (14 with armour) HD2 Club d5, Nat 19 1d10 Blunt Trauma or Spell (see above). S13 D14 C11 P13 W8 Ch10 L7 Reac 2-4 hostile 5-7 indifferent 8-10 curious 11-12 friendly

 Dokkaebi get Disadvantage on all Charisma checks with non-dokkaebi due to their appearance and reputation for unpredictability.

Dokkaebi get Advantage on all trickery-based Dexterity checks.  

 If you try them out, please let me know how they play at the table. 

Hello and Welcome Back and Sorry.

 Well, before anything else, I have to say, if there is anyone out there actually reading this, apologies.

This blog suddenly became very irregular. What can I say - real life happened and although it didn't include anything terribly dramatic, the blog just wasn't on my mind too much for a while there. I guess this post is going to be a general catch up  and overview, and then I'll make a separate new actual post

RPGs, however, have been. In a couple of specific ways. I've been running a couple of games (Tales of Argosa) and I've been reading blogs and I've actually been reading quite a bit of fiction, which got me thinking maybe I should write a review or two. 

So I've been running a couple of ToA games for kids. One group is age 13 to 14, the other 115 to 17ish. It's been a lot of fun, even though the sessions, for reasons beyond my control, run to no more than an hour. The younger group actually played an adventure before summer break, so they mostly know the ropes, but the older group are all new to me. 

First off, I found ToA to be a good fit for these groups. Short sessions need fast, simple rules to get anything done at all. The players are largely new to playing, too, so simple is good. 

So here are my observations and what I have learned about a) running games with kids and b) running very short sessions. 

The first thing that comes to mind really speaks to both of those things: have something happen immediately. With both young players and anyway with a short session, you have to move the action forwards pretty much as soon as you're at the table. I often find myself scripting my opening comments in my head in advance, about how whatever was going down last week has moved on. The groups have to finish very promptly, for reasons of transport, so we often finish abruptly, sometimes before a scene has completely concluded. This might sound awful. It really isn't. Here's why.

Knowing this happens provides an incentive to keep the pace quick and things happening throughout the hour. It also negates any temptation to drag things out or get bogged down in minutiae. The following week, I summarise what happened and move on. I do not, in that summary, ever include character actions, however; if there are character choices or decisions pending they get returned to and played out. But otherwise, and most of the time, I skip to the end of what was happening and go to the next scene/choice/room, etc. 

And, so far at least, nobody ever minds. 

In the younger group, there are four boys and a girl. Some of the boys get insanely excited about combat and slaying monsters/bad guys. I need to keep that possibility in focus to keep them focused and maintain the 'promise of action'. I say 'promise of' because i do try not to curtail their choices by forcing action. But if I leave it too long between action scenes, some of them start to drift. And Man, do they drift! Phones, my dice, their friend's dice, their friend's phone... If they're rolling dice, its all good.

One thing that does hold their attention without dice, though is NPCs. If they're colourful. Weird accents. and occasionally allowing their suggestion for a name (such as Galgamax the dwarf, which was thrown out as a 'silly' suggestion by a player when a hesitated cos I couldn't remember the dude's name. It was quicker to go with it and everybody at the table remembers it. That NPC is never going to be far from the PCs from now on!

Younger players seem more prone to just shouting out random thoughts and ideas. They haven't learned not to. I can't stop it, so I try to make use of it. So when one of them says: "Is his (the dwarf king's son) cloak green cos there's arsenic in it? That's green!" I respond "Yes, it is; they use it as a dye for their clothes because they're resistant to poison, to it but it means humans can't wear them."

That's cannon now. I might even use it in other games. I can see it being a clue in a murder mystery where a dead local is found in a green cloak his friends don't recognise. 

They also tend to take an instant liking or dislike to NPCs based on minor details. I let that influence the roles the NPCs have quite a lot. I suppose that's good practice anyway, but its especially easy with young players because they tell you everything they're thinking. Everything.  

The older group is totally different. For a start, there are two boys and four girls. And that is different from any game I've ever run. They are very interested in meeting NPCs and in those NPCs' lives, so I do have to make sure I have some stuff to share about them. I also have to limit or at least be mindful about how many I introduce because they are ALL potentially important. But it does make it easier to run an investigation adventure, because the players are actually curious about everything;  I suspect the number of girls involved also has a significant positive impact for the girls. They can experience the game the way they want to, not just how five male players would. And I suspect there's a difference. 

The main difference between the two groups is how easy or difficult it is to keep track of, and therefore communicate back tot he players, where everyone is and what they're doing. i tend to try to keep the younger players together, or they can lose track of who is where or even where their own character is and I occasionally have to remind them that they need to tell me if they are following their friend's character or  doing what everyone else said. The older group are way easier in this regard and more or less manage that themselves. 

Money is also of almost no interest to the younger group beyond being told that they just found/earned/were given lots of it. They soon forget how much they have, or who has it or where it is, so i minimise that aspect except to maintain a loose idea of what I think they can probably afford. ToA's pricing system really helps me with this - rolling a die for prices is so much quicker and easier than looking it up!

That's pretty much all my thoughts for now. I may edit later if I think of anything else, or write another post in a few weeks.  

Tuesday, 2 June 2026

Corpse Chatter: Why Necromancy should be dangerous.

 Necromancy ought to be more dangerous.

The mood and tone of a game with supernatural elements should be dark, brooding and fearful. Things move about in the dark. And houses really are haunted, by vile things that murdered and tormented in life and have not improved with death. 

Making contact with such an entity should not be a quick, ten-second fix. It requires preparation, ritual, ceremony. Possibly sacrifice, to tear a tiny rip in the Veil between the worlds, in order to let something else back through. And the necromancer is the only one who can determine if that something is the same thing they intended to come through. That alone takes time. 


The wrong spirit can be summoned. Or the right spirit might be dominated by a more powerful one. A demon even.  

Possession also ought to be a genuine potential negative outcome of any seance. By which I mean, of course, any time a magic user tries to communicate, negotiate, interact with the dead. This stuff should never  be just a spell slot. It ought to be a ritual every single time, however short a ritual, and that should be the only way to ever 'cross the veil'. That is how Necromancy is different from other schools of magic and why you normally can't do Necromancy and other types of magic... 

Tricky, malevolent spirits or demons might try to learn a necromancer’s name during the ritual, to use as leverage, later. Because ordinarily they just wouldn't know exactly who had summoned them, but if they can trick you into telling them, then it gives them the power to track down your dead relatives, or the ghostvine more generally, and track down who is related to you and where you are and how to best make your life miserable. 

Possess your cat. 

Sounds petty, but you know, cats can go either way at the best of times... 

Start haunting your mum... 

How often do necromancers ever get called out to bust a haunting? Why not? In a fantasy world with necromancery-shit going on all the live-long day, we know that shit's real. We know the haunting isn't somebody's imagination and that poltergeists are a real threat to the peace and sanity of the household. How come we never get aggressive, strategic hauntings going down?


During these rituals, of course, ‘friendly’ souls - the spirits of those who were friends in life, or who have something to gain from the interaction, ought to be much more easily dealt with than hostile spirits. 
Mechanically, this should work like testing for Reactions from monsters, where the circumstances of the summoning strongly influence the outcome. Despite the description of the spell ‘Speak With The Dead’ (‘Speak With Dead Souls’), ‘friendly’ spirits might give more information than was strictly requested, if the circumstances are right. Hostile spirits will lie, deceive by omission, equivocate and manipulate wherever possible.


{Outright Friendly, Somewhat Friendly, Neutral, Somewhat Hostile, Outright Hostile.} 


 Summoning the dead should be risky. 

Wednesday, 27 May 2026

I Want Psychic Warfare In My Campaign

 First things first: despite the title, this is ONLY going to happen IF my players are into it.

Second, it is part of wider issue of deciding after many years of feeling the exact opposite, that psychic powers CAN have a place in a fantasy campaign without totally ruining it. 

In Tales Of Argosa, various situations might call on a player to check for madness. They make a Will check and if they fail, they roll on the Madness Table. As a system, its cool, though I'd love an expanded table. I think 'Madness' seems an appropriate thing to call these afflictions/outcomes, because it isn't a word we really use any more - especially not in that context. And the system reflects actual mental illness poorly enough not to really be reflecting it at all. Which is a good thing. I don't want to make anyone at the table feel uncomfortable about any issues of their own they may have. 

Even having this theme or issue in a campaign or adventure clearly requires a conversation at the table about what players are all comfortable with.

This system seems to imply that the 'Veil' or the 'Void' has got too close to the player character's 'psyche' and somehow warped or touched it.  Altered it. In my setting, Dark Peak, it is the Dark that has done so, and those who are so touched can eventually be undone, losing their humanity and becoming Goblin Men. 

I'm going to introduce the opportunity, via play, for players to get rid of these afflictions (many of which are temporary anyway), by undergoing a process of discovering that the so-called 'Madness' is actually not madness at all, but a sensitivity to the Void , which manifests as psychic powers. In other words, the forces which have led to the unhappy situation have left the character's mind sufficiently altered that it can now do things it couldn't before. And I'd welcome anyone's perspective, who has mental health issues or knows anyone who has, on whether or not this is... okay? Does this make anything more difficult for people with real life issues? As a person who has suffered mental health issues themselves at times, I don't thing it does, but my issues are not everybody's and neither are my feelings, so. Let me know if you have personal experience about this.

Anyway, assuming there are no objections...

Players will have to quest for the solution. They have to travel, probably to the mountains. In my Dark Peak setting, this would be to  the Smoke Dark Mountains to the west, where they would seek out a monastery with a certain master, who was able to instruct in meditation, medication, exercises, etc. And the characters gains a unique ability. Whether they lose or keep the Madness is up to the player. 

In other systems, there may be a different mechanism to Unique Powers, but these are they powers I want to represent:

Telepathy

Minor Telekinesis

Detection of any one one of the following: evil intent, psychic powers, undead, or demons.

Telesenses (sensing other such powers) (all)

ESP (sensing living things, predators, allies, etc) (all)

 

This is pretty sketchy so far. I'm going to come back to it in a future post. 

 

 

 

Thursday, 14 May 2026

Charging Rules For Tales Of Argosa

 

In Tales of Argosa, Charging gains a PC double movement and a +2 to hit bonus. But their opponent also gains a +2 to hit bonus, so there is little to no advantage in charging beyond covering double the distance. And while covering twice the open ground may be desirable, it isn’t the only reason historical infantry charged an enemy.

But let’s contextualise this; there is a huge difference between one combatant charging an enemy foot-soldier and a charge of massed ranks of a trained infantry unit. On the other hand, in fantasy RPGs we do want to be able to do this. It’s fun and you want to have the option of imagining your Fighter hurtling into the ogre, or a unit of orcs, and it counting for something. So what might that look like?

Historically, the main reason for an infantry charge was to disrupt enemy formations. Psychologically, its intimidating, having an enraged enemy warrior hurtling towards you with an axe. And that’s easy to achieve in most OSR games: that’s a Morale check.

If the Morale check fails, the enemy routs and either a Chase ensues, or by GM caveat, the charging force/PC gets a free attack. This might not happen if the distance between the two is too great, though. If the GM really doesn’t want the NPC(s) to rout, or if they cannot, the GM can impose a -2 to hit penalty instead to simulate being intimidated.

If the Morale check succeeds, there will be a clash. In this instance, the charging force has the advantage of momentum. This is where the attackers gain a +2 to hit bonus.

If the attacking force is a substantially superior force, I might even give them Advantage, but that is a weighty bonus. I would only give this if one side were truly superior, such as highly disciplined veterans, or monstrous humanoids with natural advantage, such as ogres. I wouldn’t give it to Skorn, as they are too undisciplined. Or I might apply it if the force ‘receiving’ the charge were untrained/new recruits that have somehow passed the morale check, perhaps due to an outstanding rallying effort by a PC Bard, or to a supernatural means that doesn’t improve their fighting ability.

Finally, if the receiving force gained a Great Success on their Morale check, then I would award them a +2 to hit bonus, possibly evening out the battle at that point. Sometimes the defenders just decide to hold the line or die!

Summary: Charging provokes a Morale Check. Failure usually results in a rout, or a -2 to hit penalty if this is impossible. If the morale Check succeeds, the Charger(s) still gets a +2 to hit bonus. If there is a substantial difference in the quality of troops, in favour of the attackers, this becomes Advantage.

Hopefully, this provides more reasons to charge. If you try it out, please let me know how it goes!

Look at this first...

Irithiel of the Leafy Shade, elf longevity and the lifespan of empires

 I often don't like the way elves are presented in RPGs, to the point that I often include them only passively, through players hearing ...