Search This Blog

Sunday, 15 November 2026

Irithiel of the Leafy Shade, elf longevity and the lifespan of empires

 I often don't like the way elves are presented in RPGs, to the point that I often include them only passively, through players hearing about them but never meeting them. Often my players have been no more keen to play them that I am to introduce them, so it has worked fine.

Recently things have changed. I've run games with younger players and, of course, Rings Of Power has happened. Elves, it turns out, are cool. 

In the post Jackdog Town, I mentioned Irithiel of the Leafy Shade: 

The Emissary of the Elves, Irithiel of the Leafy Shade. This role was forced upon Irithiel, as emissary duty to humans always is, as it is basically punishment duty, though nonetheless undertaken with all sobriety and gravity. Now forced to try and understand the halfwits that are humans and even remain on good terms with some of them. 

First, that word 'Emissary'. Elves do send a member of their kind to some human settlements to represent them in some way, or to learn about humans. Okay. But its punishment duty. Nobody wants to do it because humans are crass and stupid and their art and culture are terrible. So is the food.

Flip side of this: Irithiel is no angel. They did something that pissed off all their peers enough to be... well, sent into exile, effectively. That could be something pretty serious. We have no timescale to go on, here, and I'll talk about lifespans later, but we usually assume elves live long, to some extent or other. So a ten year stretch in 'humanland' might not be such a big deal. of course, it might be longer... 

Which kind of brings us to a question that has probably been raised at countless gaming tables since 1974, and was recently raised at mine: how long do elves live?

There are a range of lifespans given for elves across different TTRPGs.

In Pathfinder 2e, they get about 600 years, which is decent. In Warhammer Fantasy they get over 1000, which is more decent. Shadowrun gives them 300 or 400 and Dragonage only gives them 80 to 120 years. Tight! Then there is The One Ring, of course, which makes them immortal, as Tolkien intended... 

I asked my players what they wanted. One said 130, barely out of adolescence, a young elf. Fine. Another said '"Thousands of years...". And my reaction was complicated. I was torn. Between "Yikes! How am I going to manage all the stuff he knows about the world? Why is he still only Level 1?" and "Cool...".

I went with the Rule Of Cool. 

We still haven't settled on an exact number of thousands, however, and there is some stuff to unpack around that I thought would be interesting to reflect on here, because I graduated in History and have a strong interest in Medieval and Ancient History.

 The main question worth asking, I think, is "What difference will it make at the table?" This is always my first question. The next question is "What are the implications for world-building?" which I think in the long run, may be the more impactful.

The first question is actually simple to answer. In Tales Of Argosa, which I'm currently running, and most other games, it make NO difference at all. And that's fine. I used to struggle with how a 500 year old being is still first level, now I don't. I. Just. Don't. No fulfilment lies therein. Separate the mechanics and the world in your head and let it be. Learn acceptance. Think about more important things.  I mean sure you can give them a bit more background knowledge but in terms of mechanics... meh. 

Almost any path you go down that is any way 'realistic' (or 'simulationist', if you prefer) makes elf characters overpowered, so it's better just to rely on in-world knowledge or nothing at all and assume they had a sheltered life OR that Level 1 stats represent an average being of any race/species.

In terms of world-building, its a slightly different matter, though. I was thinking about how a very long elf lifespan would see the world around them. I did some research into the timescale of a particular popular fantasy trope: the Empire.

By some measures, the Chinese Empire could be described as the longest lasting empire in history, at 2,132 years, from 221BC to 1912CE. But it usually isn't, as most historians see it as a succession of distinct empires, (which we refer to as dynasties). While the fundamental bureaucracy, writing system and cultural identity remained constant, the ruling families changed entirely many times. There were periods of fragmentation and long periods of division. Most of the dynasties lasted 200 to 300 years, which is in line with most empires. 

The Roman Empire is often cited as the longest lasting major empire, if you count (and you should) the continuation of the Eastern Roman Empire. That gives a duration of about 1500 years, from the rise of Augustus in 27 BCE to the fall of Constantinople in 1453 CE. Of course, the Republic probably began around 500 BCE... 

The Pandyan dynasty in southern India stretched across 1800 year but with interruptions. The Kanem-Bornu Empire lasted about 1000 years. The Holy Roman Empire only lasted 844 years and the ottoman Empire 623 years.

Empires don't last that long. At least, not in comparison to elves.

Elves with thousands of years' lifespan would outlive most empires several times over. Why wouldn't they assist such empires to last longer and become more 'civilised' or 'humane' than many of the empires I've mentioned were? Some of these questions of course, are answered, or at least asked, more often in vampire fiction, than in fantasy. immortality, as such fiction often shows, comes at a price. 

Ultimately, it doesn't matter how you answer these questions, but I feel you must answer it (or I must) if your elves live that long, in order to preserve any sense of verisimilitude.

If you decide your elves enjoy extreme longevity, then how many empires do you want your elf player character to remember? Put another way, how many do you want to have to invent or describe to your players? And it gets worse, not better, if you don't have empires. Empires are easy. Without one, you have a dozen smaller states to describe that are all much less stable, shift borders, invade each other, suffer catastrophes like plages and earthquakes, develop new religions, disappear... Horrible. 

My decision has been formulated like this:

My campaign world has an empire already, coming to the end of its lifespan. I am now going to say its about 1500 years old. The older elf character can remember its inception and a little of what came before (vaguely... it was messy and very human...). That way, the character becomes a channel for me to communicate anything i want about the empire. 

If we go back any further things get tricky.

If we use Europe as a guide, 6000 years ago, farming was spreading out of Anatolia into western Europe. Soon after, it reached Britain and Ireland. Weaving was taking off. We don't really know how long the spread of these ideas took exactly but probably between 2500 and 3000 years. If your elves live much longer than that, then they pretty much all saw the rise of humanity and human scholars have NO questions they can't answer, there is NO history that is not known and there are NO mysteries left to unearth. 

In addition, elves would probably have been involved the whole time, there at the beginning, so to speak, so would have had an impact.

For this reason, I think its better if they are not too long-lived. 

If elves live for say, 3000 years, then an elf lifespan would still mostly cover the spread of civilisation across a whole region, just. An elf that old now in my world can remember the rise of the local empire and some of what came before, maybe the initial war of conquest, the state that gave rise to it, the emperor as a child. But they wouldn't remember first hand what came before. And any elves younger than that (i.e. most of them) would not remember a time when humans didn't farm, but might remember times when they were not so good at it. There can still be things they don't know (like the time when humans arose before, or the empire of giants, etc) and there can be things their parents told them about seeing, but they were not there for. And of course, there can be older beings and races/species and cultures. 

 Which raises an interesting point about our friend Irithiel.

 How old are they? And how does that impact on their role as emissary to Jackdog Town? Because I would normally associate roles such as 'emissary' with mature, probably powerful individuals. But if its a punishment duty, that might suggest someone young enough to make a mistake. I think it might be something decided on a case by case basis. Either way, Irithiel is there and they're the only elf, most of the time, and they're going to be bored. 

 What is Irithiel doing in that time? Well they'd probably go nuts if they were doing nothing, so lets not make that assumption. They could, of course, just get bored and take themselves off a-wandering.  And I guess that's where elf adventurers come from. Of they could bard it up for a while, doubtless gaining renowned as the finest in the land. But unless they're in a big city, that just seems mean to all the human bards struggling to make a name and get by. If you go a little bit Tolkien here, they could spend their time teaching humans about music and song, elf history, etc. But only those humans wealthy enough not to spend all day in a field. Irithiel would end up a 'court bard' pretty quick, or at least ensconced in the local castle or keep. Which might be no bad thing. Yes, that could work quite well.

If not, maybe they serve as emissary within a wider area. A kind of travelling representative, spending a few weeks in each settlement, with a well-earned break from human yammering, on the roads between. 

And for how long would they be carrying out this duty? Well I suppose there's no fixed rule; the elf elders with responsibility for oversight of Irithiel would choose a time to 'extract' him that caused minimum disruption to human affairs. If the local lord is stable and secure and his domain the same, then an elf in exile could potentially spend a human lifetime there. Say, thirty years or more. And of an elf can reliably expect to live 3000 years, that 1% of their lifetime, the equivalent of about eight months, to a human who lives to be 70. An elf could learn a lot about humans in that time. A not teach anything dangerous in return, if they're a young individual. If the domain falls into civil war, however, or is subject to plague or invasion, then maybe you pull Irithiel out, deploy them somewhere safer. 

We should not discount the possibility that there could be a specific and possibly dark purpose to an elf's investigating, either. They could be trying to understand how much of a threat human populations pose to elf. Or there might be reason to suspect a greater threat at large in the area (a la Necromancer in the forest). Or they might be tasked with finding out how a local sorcerer nobody used to take notice of has somehow mustered an army of lion-folk. 

 All of which points to a couple of conclusions. 

There is nothing wrong with giving elves serious longevity. We will need to think about it a bit more, but it will also allow his to feed more background to players if we need to. 

We need to answer a few questions, one way or another, such as exact longevity influence upon human culture, deep history, etc. in order to build elves more fully into our campaign setting, including  how much history we actually want write/read/have to remember.

And we should consider whether our particular answers to any of these questions are likely to influence whether or not players actually choose to play elves. Because at the end of the day, that's the whole point. 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Look at this first...

Irithiel of the Leafy Shade, elf longevity and the lifespan of empires

 I often don't like the way elves are presented in RPGs, to the point that I often include them only passively, through players hearing ...